Evidence record · M-002
r/Ubiquiti removes UI-Tom as moderator
An r/Ubiquiti moderator announced Tom's removal after community objections, while crediting his earlier work and saying the team knew about his Ubiquiti employment. Suddenly_Engineer agreed with the decision, wrote that he should have stepped down years earlier, and acknowledged that retaining privileges on a personal account undermined community trust.
M-002DocumentedAn r/Ubiquiti moderator announced Tom's removal after community objections, while crediting his earlier work and saying the team knew about his Ubiquiti employment. Suddenly_Engineer agreed with the decision, wrote that he should have stepped down years earlier, and acknowledged that retaining privileges on a personal account undermined community trust.
What this shows
- The announcement is authored by u/iKjQ2a4v. Suddenly_Engineer addresses his reply to Jon, and the publisher identifies u/iKjQ2a4v as Jon's Reddit account.
- An r/Ubiquiti moderator announced that UI-Tom would be removed as a moderator.
- The announcement says Tom had been a moderator before joining Ubiquiti and disclosed the employment to the moderator team after he was hired.
- The announcement says the team kept him because it valued his contributions and believed his limited moderation activity was overseen.
- Suddenly_Engineer publicly agreed with the removal and said he should have stepped down years earlier.
- Suddenly_Engineer said maintaining a personal account with moderation privileges undermined community trust.
What this does not show
- The exact date on which all Reddit permissions were technically revoked.
- The internal deliberations that led to the announcement.
- Who performed any earlier moderation action.
You and the other moderators made the right call. I didn't think about my impact on the community while maintaining the moderator role, and that's on me. I should have stepped down years ago, and maintaining a personal account with moderation privileges has undermined community trust.
Verified speaker: Suddenly_Engineer · Attribution verified